Evidence suggests e-cigarettes not healthy alternative

Published 12:21 pm Saturday, November 30, 2019

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

By Eric Galatas

Texas News Service

AUSTIN, Texas – In the wake of recent reports of fatal lung illness connected with the use of e-cigarettes, new research seems to confirm concerns about the health impacts of vaping.
A study by Boston University researchers found that e-cigarettes altered cholesterol levels, and Dr. Florian Rader, a cardiologist at the Smidt Heart Institute at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, says his group’s research suggests that vaping may be more harmful to heart health than traditional cigarettes.
“And now our study adds to the evidence that e-cigarette smoking may not be quite as healthy as it’s being portrayed,” Rader said. “And I think that there’s reason enough for now to be at least cautious.”
Rader compared the blood flow of 10 non-smokers, 10 tobacco cigarette smokers and 10 e-cigarette users.
Testing blood flows at rest and while squeezing a hand grip, only e-cigarette users showed signs of coronary vascular dysfunction, even when they were not exerting themselves physically.
Industry groups have previously argued that vaping is a healthy alternative to traditional cigarettes, especially for people trying to kick their smoking habit.
Commercials for e-cigarettes do warn about the health risks of nicotine, but Katie Jones, executive director of the American Lung Association in Texas, says there’s no evidence that electronic cigarettes are an effective cessation device.
“The thing with e-cigarettes is they contain chemicals that are harmful to lung health, such as heavy metals, carcinogens,” she points out. “And especially for children or for teens or young adults, their lungs are still developing.”
A recent study by the Food and Drug Administration found that a quarter of all high school students used e-cigarettes in 2019, up five percentage points from last year.
Rader notes his group’s initial research and limited trial size could benefit from further studies, and testing health impacts over time, to determine the true impacts of vaping on public health.